Unit Investment Trust (UIT) versus Mutual Funds (which also include the closed-end mutual funds) are two popular terms when funds are being discussed in the context of investment planning. Both vehicle categories allow investors to access diversified portfolios of securities, but they differ in structure, management, pricing, and liquidity. Within the context of achieving financial goals, understanding such differences helps investors align their investment decisions.
What is a Unit Investment Trust?
A unit investment trust (UIT) is an investment company that offers a fixed portfolio of securities, generally bonds or stocks, for a specific period. UITs’ creators set their portfolios for a set duration with a more or less fixed portfolio and, once established, seldom actively manage them. Once the trust is established, the portfolio remains intact until the securities reach maturity or the trust dissolves. Investors buy units in the trust, which represent a proportionate share of the underlying holdings.
What Are Mutual Funds?
Mutual funds also serve as investment vehicles, although they differ somewhat from a UIT in structure and management style. Classification-wise, mutual funds fall under open-ended or closed-end. Open-end mutual funds issue and redeem shares at NAV continuously; closed-end mutual funds, on the other hand, issue a fixed number of shares through an initial public offering (IPO) and trade the shares on an exchange thereafter.
Major Points of Difference between UITs and Mutual Funds
- Structure and Management
UITs maintain a fixed portfolio, and their managers do not actively trade or rebalance once the trust is created. Closed-end mutual funds are actively managed; fund managers decide what to buy and sell during the life of the fund.
- Trading and Pricing
Generally, brokers sell UITs through the initial offering period or in secondary markets at NAV. Thus, the sale and related methods of mutual funds differ in all respects. Investors trade closed-end mutual fund shares on stock exchanges, and these may not reflect NAV because of market forces. The price of closed-end mutual fund shares can be greater or less than their NAV
- Liquidity
Limited liquidity exists for UITs through either redemption by the sponsor or resale in the secondary market. Traders have higher liquidity for the fund available through the stock exchange, although the price received may not match the NAV for closed-end mutual funds.
- Dividends and Distributions
UITs distribute earnings from interest or dividends when they receive them, and these are not reinvested within the trust. The latter offers dividend reinvestment plans, and closed-end mutual funds can reinvest their earnings to compound returns.
- Costs and Fees
Since UITs do not have active management, their fees remain predictable and are typically limited to creation and maintenance charges. Closed-end mutual funds can vary widely in fees due to active management, including management fees, administrative costs, and, in some cases, performance-based fees.
Similarities Between UITs and Mutual Funds
Despite these diverging views, UITs and mutual funds share some common features. Both give investors access to a diversified portfolio of assets. Each registers with and is regulated by the SEC under the Investment Company Act of 1940. Both systems offer an understanding of the composition, underlying investments, and performance of the offered securities through prospectuses and periodic reports.
Tax Considerations
Both UITs and mutual funds pass through taxable income to investors. In the case of UITs, capital gains or losses arise upon portfolio maturity or on sale of the securities. In the case of closed-end mutual funds, capital gains can be distributed periodically depending on the level of portfolio turnover and trading activity.
Investors should take time to analyze their tax situations and consult with a financial or tax adviser before making any decisions regarding investments in UITs or closed-end funds.
Use Cases and Investor Suitability
Investors with an interest in UITs may favor fixed income distributions and securities under a fixed portfolio and investment horizon, which precedes lesser investment income. They utilize UITs generally for purposes of income and defined sectoral exposure.
Whereas an appropriate closed-end fund will interest the investor who understands fluctuations in market-based pricing and wants managed exposure to a diversified portfolio of securities. Trading on an exchange allows investors to strategically define entry and exit points.
Conclusion
Investors choose between a unit investment trust and closed-end mutual funds based on several factors, such as investment goals, time horizon, risk tolerance, and preference for active or passive management.
Leave a Reply